A UK tribunal has dismissed a £2 billion class-action lawsuit against PlayStation, which claimed that consumers were subjected to unfair pricing due to a 30% commission on the PlayStation Store
The UK competition authorities have dismissed a long-standing class action lawsuit that accused Sony of monopolistic practices and price manipulation concerning PlayStation games. This follows a trial held earlier in the year.
The lawsuit, initiated in 2022 by consumer advocate Alex Neill, asserted that Sony's creation of a "closed ecosystem" allowed it to impose "excessive and unfair" fees on downloads from the PlayStation Store, affecting digital users who had no choice but to comply. Neill argued that without these practices, digital game prices could be around 20% lower.
The legal claim, encompassing 12.2 million PlayStation Store users, proposed compensation of £162 each, amounting to roughly £2 billion ($2.6 billion) in total. The Competition Appeal Tribunal rejected the claim entirely, stating that consumers had other choices such as physical game copies—though Sony recently stated plans to end these—and competing gaming systems.
Furthermore, the tribunal found that transforming Sony's ecosystem into one that could support third-party stores would be costly and could compromise security and performance. It stated there is substantial evidence showing that consumers are inclined to shift to other consoles if PlayStation game prices rise, as indicated by Sony's own research warning of potential commercial damage if PlayStation games became noncompetitive with Xbox.
The tribunal concluded that the claim's argument of a closed ecosystem was mostly theoretical and not realistic, and the competitive price suggested in the claim—20% lower than the current retail price—was unsubstantiated.
In a similar past case, Apple was ruled against in 2025 for exploiting its market position via the App Store's 30% commission. Apple has since allowed alternative web stores, spurring growth in third-party platforms like Xsolla and AppCharge.