It's like burying money and people in the ground: the former head of Take-Two explained why developing modern AAA games is unprofitable
Ben Feder, who led Take-Two Interactive from 2007 to 2011, gave a substantial interview to The Game Business. During the conversation, he spoke about the current issues in AAA development.
GTA VI
According to Feder, the game development industry is currently not in the best condition. Studios are closing, employees are being laid off, and the competition for audience attention is rapidly increasing. He sees a silver lining in these events — amidst this turmoil, companies are beginning to adopt new technologies and spend money more wisely. Nevertheless, the former head of Take-Two is convinced that under such conditions, AAA game developers are taking significant risks.
The issue, Feder explains, is that modern AAA games are too massive for their creators to afford to experiment. Yet, they are still too small to transform from mere games into full-fledged platforms.
The situation is worsened by the high cost of production. Feder remarks that major publishers he spoke with do not understand how to make AAA games for less than 300 million dollars. The lengthy development timelines concern the former head of Take-Two just as much.
“Approving the production of a game with a budget of 300 million dollars and a development timeline of five years is like taking a development team, putting them in a time capsule, burying them underground for the entire duration, and waiting for them to emerge and say, ‘Voilà, here is our game.’ Three to five years ago, such an approach was quite reasonable. We knew what the team was working on, and we knew they had a strong IP and a niche in the market. We also knew what the world would look like when they surfaced. But today, while developers are inside their capsule, enormous changes are occurring on the outside — not only technologies but also tastes and consumer expectations are evolving. When the game eventually releases, it might no longer matter to the world,” stated Feder.
The exception, according to Feder, is GTA VI, as it is indeed capable of transcending ordinary games and approaching platforms. However, replicating its success is extremely difficult: this would require operating with budgets not in the millions, but in the billions of dollars.
